HomePriceMap

Home › Counties › Cayuga County, NY

Median Home Price in Cayuga County, NY

The median home value in Cayuga County, NY is $233,044, up 5.14% from a year earlier.

County housing-data period: October 2026. County source retrieval/check time (UTC) is recorded in the feed's updated field when available, not in the housing-data period.

Checked daily for new monthly Zillow releases, not new daily prices. Income and crime data are updated separately, not by the daily housing-data check. Unavailable means observation dates are missing or invalid.

Median Home Value

$233,044

Year-over-Year

+5.14%

National Rank

#1499 of 3107

Cayuga County ranks 39th out of 62 counties in NY by median home price, and is +2.0% above the U.S. national median of $228,374. Within NY, the typical county has a median home value of $252,014, making Cayuga County -7.5% below the NY state median.

View Cayuga County on the interactive county map →

Compare Cayuga County with another place

Home value history

The typical home value increased by 0.8%, from $231,296 in May 2026 to $233,044 in Oct 2026.

Cayuga County, NY typical home value from May 2026 to Oct 2026

Monthly Zillow Home Value Index snapshots retained by HomePriceMap. A short history is shown now and grows automatically as each new monthly release arrives.

Cayuga County, NY monthly home value history
MonthTypical home valueYear-over-year change
May 2026$231,296+6.0%
Jun 2026$239,128+6.2%
Jul 2026$238,643+6.1%
Aug 2026$235,844+6.0%
Sep 2026$235,019+5.7%
Oct 2026$233,044+5.1%

Can you afford a home in Cayuga County?

Households here earn a median of $67,904 a year against a typical home value of $233,044 — a price-to-income ratio of 3.4×, above the 3× level usually considered comfortable, but below 5×. That is less affordable than roughly 45% of U.S. counties. (How this is calculated.)

Crime in Cayuga County

Reporting agencies in Cayuga County recorded a violent crime rate of 245 per 100,000 residents in 2024 — around the middle of the national range. Property crime runs at 1,342 per 100,000.

Based on 1 reporting city covering 25,699 residents (FBI UCR data — what this covers).

Common questions about Cayuga County

How much does a house cost in Cayuga County, NY?

The median home value in Cayuga County is $233,044. That's up 5.14% from a year earlier. That is about 2.0% above the U.S. national county median of $228,374, and makes Cayuga County the 39th most expensive of 62 counties in New York.

Is Cayuga County affordable?

Median household income here is $67,904, so a typical home costs about 3.4× annual household earnings — moderately expensive compared with other U.S. counties.

Is Cayuga County a safe place to live?

Reporting police departments in Cayuga County recorded 245 violent crimes per 100,000 residents. That figure covers 25,699 residents across 1 reporting city, so it reflects the county's incorporated areas rather than every community within its borders.

Cities in Cayuga County

Auburn

Counties with similar home prices in NY

Schoharie County · Livingston County · Schuyler County · Oneida County · Jefferson County · Clinton County · Fulton County · Seneca County

See the full ranked list of New York counties →