Home › Cities › Monticello, NY

Median Home Price in Monticello, NY

The median home value in Monticello, NY is $291,941 as of 2026-06-30, up 2.94% from a year earlier.

Median Home Value

$291,941

Year-over-Year

+2.94%

Population

7,216

Monticello ranks #60 of 95 New York cities tracked here by median home value, and sits 34.6% below the state's city median of $446,289. It sits in Sullivan County, where the county-wide median is $328,990.

Crime in Monticello

Monticello police recorded a violent crime rate of 111 per 100,000 residents in 2024 — around the middle of the range for reporting cities. Property crime runs at 1,621 per 100,000.

Reported by the city's own police department to the FBI's Uniform Crime Reporting Program (what this covers).

Common questions about Monticello

How much does a house cost in Monticello, NY?

The median home value in Monticello is $291,941. That's up 2.94% from a year earlier. That is about 34.6% below the typical county in New York.

Is Monticello expensive compared to the surrounding area?

Homes in Monticello are cheaper than Sullivan County as a whole, where the median is $328,990 — a difference of about 11.3%.

Is Monticello a safe place to live?

Monticello police reported 111 violent crimes per 100,000 residents, covering a population of about 7,216. Crime rates are one input among many — they vary block to block within a city, and this figure is a citywide average.